State to release school letter grades to public despite controversy

by Sean Shanks, Staff Writer

Posted 11/18/26

OWENSVILLE — The Missouri State Board of Education is moving forward with a state-mandated letter grading system meant to allow parents to easily and simply compare schools, despite pushback from …

This item is available in full to subscribers.

Please log in to continue

E-mail
Password
Log in

State to release school letter grades to public despite controversy

Posted

OWENSVILLE — The Missouri State Board of Education is moving forward with a state-mandated letter grading system meant to allow parents to easily and simply compare schools, despite pushback from school districts and other stakeholders.

Gov. Mike Kehoe signed an executive order in January that mandates the implementation of the grading system by the Missouri Department of Elementary and Secondary Education (DESE). It aims to use a combination of metrics, including:

• Standardized test scores

• Metrics based on improvement in those scores

• Metrics based on graduation rates

Those values would be combined to calculate a single letter grade assigned to each building in each district, as well as to the district as a whole. The grades will be released to the public on Dec. 15 and were calculated using data from 2024-25 that is now two years old.

“In the implementation so far, it’s become very complicated in terms of explaining or understanding how the calculations are even done, so that’s going to be interesting when that comes out to families whether that muddies the water or makes it more clear,” said Superintendent Staci Johnson.

The Gasconade County R-2 Board of Education approved a resolution on Oct. 19 that opposed the grading system and urged the “Missouri General Assembly to enact legislation prohibiting the use of a single summative letter grade for public schools and districts or, at a minimum, requiring that any state rating system be authorized in statute and adopted through rule-making with public comment.”

DESE already puts together a comprehensive annual performance report for each school district. However, the A-F grading system uses some growth-based metrics DESE would not have used in the past. Of course, there is limited room for continued growth, so some have questioned whether a focus on improvement will negatively affect the grade of schools with sustained high test scores.

“If you’re already high achieving, it’s very hard to make a large amount of growth each year,” Johnson said. So, theoretically, a school could steadily improve its standardized testing scores over the next three years and receive higher grades due to that growth. But in the following three years, they could see their grade take a hit, despite sustained success, because there is little more room to grow.

Another perceived issue with the grading system is that it largely ignores the significant portion of high school students who are focused on a trade or craft and have no desire to take college preparatory exams like the SAT and ACT. They may need to take a test in a class that has nothing to do with their desired career, but that will still impact the overall grade of the school.

“For us, half of our graduating cohort goes to a trade school or goes directly into the workforce,” Johnson said. “You’re going to see a huge divide between suburban letter grades and rural letter grades.”

The state school board has taken in some feedback from meetings with superintendents and other stakeholders, according to Johnson, like an addition to the calculations that takes a school district’s poverty level into account. But she says the main issue is that a simplified grading system does not capture the subtleties of the educational process.

“The problem is, the feedback that they’re getting is that, philosophically, everyone is opposed to this idea. They’re saying we have to do it, so we’re going to do it this way.” Meanwhile, schools and other organizations still think that it is a fundamentally bad idea, Johnson said.

In one meeting, Johnson asked the school board why the calculation guidelines were changed in a manner that would place more schools in the C-F range. She did not receive an answer to her question.

“Outside looking in, it looks like it was adjusted so more schools are failing,” she said.

Eight other states have attempted to enact a similar grading system. Five of those have already replaced or eliminated the system due to perceived inadequacies. Johnson worries that in Missouri, the grading system could affect employee morale. Teachers and administrators tell their students that a single letter grade does not define them and their future, but are faced with a method of accountability that boils everyone’s hard work down to one letter grade.

“The stated purpose is simplicity, but the problem is that in implementation they’re finding it’s not simple,” Johnson said. “It’s a very complex issue. Any reliance on a high-stakes assessment that your stakeholders had no part in creating just sets the system up against every district.”

Melissa Randol is the executive director of the Missouri School Boards’ Association. In an editorial by the Missouri Times, Randol questioned whether the State Board of Education and the Governor’s office should be creating another framework for holding schools accountable when it has failed to provide full funding to schools. In September, the state board chose not to request full funding for public schools from the Missouri Legislature. The R-2 school district predicts that it will be underfunded by $671,812, according to a recent press release.

“Did the state keep its commitments? Did it provide schools with the resources necessary to meet the standards it imposed? Did it give struggling schools a genuine path to improve — or simply a new label announcing that they are struggling?” Randol said.

The Gasconade County Republican reached out to the Governor’s office multiple times for comment, but received no response.